Boozy Pirate Cake
Filed Under (Baking, Sweet Treats) by maida on 28-04-2009
My birthday is coming up (tomorrow, actually) and to celebrate, my friends and hubby treated me to a delicious dinner at Basil, then dancing at Bootie this past Saturday. Matt was a guest DJ at Bootie and I try to go see him play when I can. He didn’t disappoint– it was an awesome fun time! Bootie is a mashup club in San Francisco run by some of my hubby’s good friends and it’s always a good time. If you’re curious about mashups, here’s my favorite (made by my husband, of course):
dj-matt-hite-everybody-is-right
I made my own cake because I can’t resist any opportunity to make cake. It’s something I find enjoyable and it’s good practice. I will be good at making cakes one day! Since we were partying it up at Bootie, I went with a pink pirate themed cake. Get it– bootie, like pirates treasure booty. Aargh!
The only problem is that my pirate that was supposed to go on top didn’t turn out. Vegan white chocolate, while hard to find, doesn’t melt as well as non-vegan white chocolate. That, and the fact that somebody’s little fingers kept messing with it (Emma!!), caused my pirate to fall apart when I went to put her on my cake. I’ll give the technique another try later. Anyway, so my pirate fell apart and I didn’t have the time/motivation to attempt another. I ran off to the party supply store only to find a very small selection of pirate-themed party supplies, none of them pink, so I went with Hello Kitty instead. Then I made her an eye patch out of chocolate fondant and that was my pirate cake!
The cake itself was the chocolate cake recipe from The Joy of Vegan Baking with a few teaspoons of coffee extract added to the batter. I baked it (2 separate batches) in two 6-inch cake pans, for a total of 4 layers. The buttercream in between the layers was a Kahlua Mocha Buttercream and it was so boozily delicious.
Kahlua Mocha Buttercream Frosting
(click here for a printer-friendly version)
1/2 cup non-hydrogenated shortening
1/2 cup non-hydrogenated, non-dairy margarine
5 cups powdered sugar, sifted
3/4 cups unsweetened cocoa powder
1/4 cup (2 oz) good, dark chocolate, melted and cooled (or more cocoa powder)
8 TB Kahlua
2 tsp vanilla extract
3 tsp coffee extract
Cream together the shortening and margarine. Gradually add the powdered sugar, cocoa powder and melted chocolate (your chocolate MUST be cooled, or it will melt the shortening and margarine and you will have a big mess on your hands). Add the Kahlua and extracts. If your frosting is too thin, add more sugar. If too thick, add a splash more of Kahlua.
A few things first: Good-tasting vegan fondant is hard to come by, unless you make it yourself. After much research and experimentation, I have come up with a yummy chocolate rolled fondant recipe with an option to leave it a white rolled fondant. Since I used chocolate fondant for my pirate cake, here’s how I made it:
(click here for a printer-friendly version)
Makes enough to cover a 10″ x 4″ high cake
¼ cup cold water
1 TB agar-agar flakes*
2 pounds (8 cups) powdered sugar, sifted
½ cup cocoa powder (omit if you want white fondant)
½ cup light corn syrup
1 ½ TB glycerin
2 TB non-hydrogenated shortening
1 tsp vanilla extract (omit if you want white fondant)
1. Do not attempt to make this unless you can devote a solid, uninterrupted hour to it. It probably won’t take you that long, but it’s not something that you can leave and come back to.
2. Put the cold water into a small sauce pan. Sprinkle the agar-agar flakes on top and set aside.
3. Divide the powdered sugar between two large bowls. In one of the bowls, add the cocoa powder to the 4 cups of powdered sugar. Make a well in the center. Set aside.
4. Now that the agar-agar flakes have had a chance to soften in the water, turn the heat to medium to cook them. Do not attempt to cook on high heat. Low and slow is the rule here! This is the most important step in the process of making fondant because you need to be completely sure that all of the agar flakes are dissolved before proceeding.
Notice all of the “speckles” at the bottom of the pan-those are the still undissolved agar flakes. As the water begins to dissolve the agar, the mixture at the bottom will become gelatinous. Add more water slowly (a tablespoon at a time), let it dissolve more agar, then add more until there are no more speckles of flakes visible in the pan. You may end up adding more than cup of water to fully dissolve the flakes, but you need to do so gradually so as not to add too much. The process of dissolving the agar takes probably 15 minutes.
And that’s what it should look like– gelatinous goo at the bottom of the pan.
5. Add the rest of the ingredients to the pan and stir to combine. Pour this mixture into the well inside the bowl of powdered sugar and cocoa. Begin stirring, incorporating a little more powdered sugar from the outside of the well at a time.
6. When all of the sugar from this bowl has been incorporated, start adding scoops of sugar that have been reserved in the other bowl. When the mixture becomes too stiff to stir with a spoon, knead it with your hands.
7. Knead in more sugar until the mixture doesn’t stick to your hands or the bowl anymore. You will probably only use about 6 cups of sugar total.
8. Shape the fondant into a ball, wrap tightly with plastic wrap and allow to rest at room temperature overnight before using.
9. To make white fondant, follow this same recipe and process, but omit the cocoa powder and vanilla extract.
* I have only used agar-agar flakes for this recipe. I have not tried powder. If you do intend to use agar powder, use 2 tsp max. EDIT: If you find this recipe by a random web search, check out this post for more information on using agar-agar powder instead of flakes. I find that powder produces a better finished product than flakes do.
So let’s revisit the boob cake:
I made up a batch of vanilla cake, but baked it in a small stainless steel bowl. It took a long time, probably 40 minutes, for the center to be completely done. Once cooled, I carved them to be roughly the same sized domes then covered them in a thin layer of chocolate buttercream, and then covered them with fondant (the same fondant recipe above). I made white fondant (omitting the cocoa powder and vanilla) then tinted it with a few drops of yellow and red food coloring paste. To achieve a true skin tone, I kneaded in several tablespoons of cocoa powder (a little at a time). A few more drops of red added to the skin-tone fondant makes the nips.






















Thanks for the fondant recipe!
I took a few cake decorating classes but it was just piping, no fondant work. I’ve been curious and wanted to try making and using fondant myself, but never knew what to put in it!
And your Hello Kitty pirate is adorable. ^^
I know it sounds complicated, but it really is quite easy to make. I was pretty surprised at how easy and inexpensive it is to make at home (and at how much better it tastes than the stuff you can buy at the store).
That cake is too cute and it sounds so good!
Happy Birthday!!!!!
Your bootie cake looks amazing (as always)! Lots of chocolaty goodness there.
Thanks!
Your cake is soooo cute!! And happy birthday!! Glad to read you had a good time, and Matt ‘s DJing – as always – was amazing! I wish we’d gotten to hang out with you more that night, but it was a total madhouse, as I’m sure you know… It’s a couple days late, but we wish the best in this upcoming year, happy birthday! And thanks for sharing your BDAY and HUSBAND with Bootie this last Saturday!! And again, LOVE the cake! Too cool to find this! xoxo Deidre (& Adrian)
Thank you! It was a fun night- and, yes, a total madhouse. If I thought it was a madhouse, you probably felt it was a madhouse times a billion. I’ll share my husband with Bootie anytime you’d like to borrow him!
[...] you use my fondant recipe, follow as directed, except use about 1 1/2 tsp of agar powder for agar flakes. You may need to [...]
Can this only be used to cover a cake or can it be used to mould characters and things for cake toppers?
This recipe is actually better for making characters than it is for covering a cake. The recipe needs a little bit of work so that it’s good for both. I find that when I roll it out to cover a cake, it’s dry and starts to crack. If I add shortening or glycerin to make it a little more moist, it sticks to whatever it is that I’m rolling it out on. *sigh* So, for covering a cake, I stick with store bought fondant. For making little fondant characters, this recipe is great. It does not dry hard like gum paste does, though.
Thank you for your recipe Making a large 5 tiered vegan 21 bithday cake for daughter. To make the fondant more pliable add more glycerin to the recipe. Also for molding you need to add 1 tsp of gum tragacanth to the fondant. It will make your figures cleaner and better.
Thanks for the tip. I’ve tried adding more glycerin and it usually just turns into a big, gooey mess. Lately, I’ve been relying on the Wilton fondant, which tastes nasty, but is much easier to work with. One of these days, I hope to find the time to fiddle with my recipe a bit to make it better for covering cakes. I’ve also heard of people making a fondant-like covering out of chocolate or white chocolate. This sounds more like a modeling chocolate to me, but I bet it tastes better than the Wilton fondant. I just wish vegan white chocolate were more easy to find (as in I didn’t have to special order it!), so that I could give that a try without feeling guilty for wasting the money if it didn’t work.
I usually do use gum paste to make figures.
You’re a lifesaver! I’ve been vegan and making vegan cakes for 15 years but am just now getting into fondant. Not wanting to use the crappy, chemical-filled fondant from the store, I decided I needed to make my own. Now you’ve spelled it out for me. Thank you!
That fondant recipe is great for modeling figures, but I had a really hard time getting it to roll out properly. Maybe you can fiddle around with the recipe and let me know if you figure out how to get it to roll without sticking to everything. Most of the time, I end up using the gross store bought (but vegan!) fondant because it’s so much easier to work with. I would love to be able to make it myself, though.
Making it this week for my class final. I’ll keep you posted.